Can Trump Legally Stop Asylum at the US Border? Supreme Court Case 2026

โ€ข

The Supreme Court Case Explained

Imagine arriving at the United States border after fleeing threats, persecution or violence in your home country. You are hoping to ask the authorities for protection, but instead you are told that you cannot apply for asylum under a new government policy.

What happens next? Can the president legally prevent someone from even submitting an asylum application? Does the federal government have the power to introduce a faster removal process that operates outside the procedures established by Congress? And, perhaps more importantly, what happens when a presidential immigration policy appears to conflict with existing federal law?

These are some of the questions now attracting attention in the United States legal system.

On November 13, 2026, the US Supreme Court agreed to examine a major immigration dispute involving President Donald Trump’s restrictions on access to asylum at the southern border. The case, officially listed as Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al. v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, et al., concerns the legal limits of presidential authority and the role of federal courts in protecting statutory immigration procedures.

The dispute has already passed through a federal district court and the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Both courts reached decisions against important parts of the administration’s policy. The government has now asked the Supreme Court to review the dispute and reverse the lower courts’ conclusions.

However, the justices have not yet decided whether the policy is lawful. Their November 13 action means that they have agreed to hear arguments on two legal questions. A ruling on the substance of the dispute is still ahead.

The case matters because its outcome could influence how future American presidents exercise immigration powers, how asylum applications are handled and how far federal judges can go when issuing orders that protect groups of people affected by government policies.

To understand why the dispute has reached the country’s highest court, it is necessary to examine the presidential proclamation, the immigration law behind the controversy and the arguments made by both sides.

What Is the US Supreme Court Asylum Case About?

The case is commonly known as Mullin v. RAICES, although earlier proceedings also used the name RAICES v. Noem.

RAICES stands for the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, one of the organisations involved in the legal challenge.

The dispute began after President Donald Trump issued a presidential proclamation on January 20, 2025, shortly after returning to office. The proclamation introduced restrictions relating to people entering the United States through the southern border.

Its official title was Proclamation 10888, Guaranteeing the States Protection Against Invasion.

The administration argued that the situation at the southern border amounted to an invasion and that the government needed to take additional measures to regain control of entry into the country.

Among other things, the proclamation directed the federal government to suspend the entry of people described as participating in the invasion across the southern border. It also sought to prevent covered individuals from invoking provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act that could allow them to remain in the country, specifically mentioning asylum.

The restrictions were designed to remain in place until the president issued a finding that the situation described in the proclamation had ended.

The federal government subsequently issued guidance to immigration officials explaining how the policy should be implemented.

That guidance became central to the legal dispute.

The issue was no longer simply whether the government could control who entered the United States. The question became whether the president could use the proclamation to establish new removal procedures and prevent certain people already present in the country from accessing protections provided by Congress.

This distinction is important because American immigration law treats the suspension of entry and the removal of someone already present in the country as separate legal matters.

The full proclamation is available through the Federal Register.

What Does American Law Say About the Right to Apply for Asylum?

To understand the disagreement, readers first need to understand what asylum means under American immigration law.

Asylum is a form of protection that may be granted to someone who meets the legal definition of a refugee and is unable or unwilling to return to their home country because of persecution or a well-founded fear of persecution on certain protected grounds.

These grounds include race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group and political opinion.

The relevant law is Section 208 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, codified at 8 U.S.C. Section 1158.

One important part of the law is Section 1158(a)(1). It provides that a person who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the country may apply for asylum, regardless of immigration status and whether or not they arrived through a designated port of entry.

This wording has become central to the dispute.

The statute does not say that every person who arrives at the border must be granted asylum. It establishes the legal opportunity to apply, subject to the requirements and exceptions contained in the law.

That difference is significant.

Submitting an asylum application is not the same as receiving approval. An applicant must still satisfy the relevant legal requirements. Immigration authorities examine the person’s circumstances and determine whether the claim qualifies for protection.

For example, someone who is fleeing general economic hardship does not automatically qualify for asylum simply because conditions in their home country are difficult. The person must establish the type of persecution and protected-ground connection required by American law, subject to the applicable rules.

The Immigration and Nationality Act also contains limitations on who may apply. These include certain safe-third-country arrangements, the general one-year filing deadline and restrictions involving previous asylum applications.

Therefore, the right to apply does not mean that the government is required to approve every claim.

The legal question in Mullin v. RAICES is whether the administration can go beyond the statutory limits and prevent an entire covered group of people from accessing the application process.

The official text of 8 U.S.C. Section 1158 provides the legal background.

How Did the Presidential Proclamation Change Border Procedures?

Following the January 2025 proclamation, the Department of Homeland Security issued instructions to immigration enforcement officials through emails, a memorandum and training materials.

The policy described in those instructions went beyond simply announcing that certain people would be denied entry.

According to the subsequent decision of the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, the guidance directed officials at the southwestern border not to permit individuals crossing between designated ports of entry to apply for asylum under the normal process.

It also established two new procedures called Direct Repatriation and Expedited Removal.

The second name requires particular care because it was not the same process as the existing statutory expedited removal procedure established by Congress.

Under the new guidance, the government created its own framework for dealing with people covered by the proclamation.

The appellate court examined how these procedures differed from the established immigration system.

Under ordinary procedures, immigration officers are required to ask certain questions when a person is being processed for removal. Those questions are intended to identify whether the individual fears persecution, harm or torture if returned to another country.

If someone expresses the required fear, they may be referred for further assessment under the relevant protection procedures.

The court explained that the challenged guidance replaced important parts of this process.

Instead of following the existing questioning and referral procedures, officials were directed to refer only individuals who spontaneously manifested fear to a more limited assessment focused on the Convention Against Torture.

That assessment did not provide the same access to asylum or statutory withholding-of-removal protections.

The appellate court also raised concerns about the removal of established opportunities to prepare evidence, consult representatives and obtain review of certain decisions.

This became an important part of the legal challenge because the plaintiffs argued that the administration had created a new system that bypassed safeguards established by federal law.

Why Did Immigrant Rights Organisations Challenge the Policy?

In February 2025, thirteen individuals and three nonprofit organisations filed a lawsuit challenging the proclamation and its implementation.

The organisations involved were:

  • Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, commonly known as RAICES.
  • Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center.
  • Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project.

The individual plaintiffs proceeded under pseudonyms in the case.

They argued that the administration had exceeded its authority by using a presidential proclamation and agency guidance to replace the immigration procedures established by Congress.

Their challenge focused on several parts of federal law, including the asylum statute, removal procedures and protections against returning people to persecution or torture.

The organisations also argued that the administration could not simply introduce a new removal system through informal guidance when Congress had already established the legal framework for handling immigration cases.

Their position was that the president could not use general immigration powers to disregard more specific requirements contained in the Immigration and Nationality Act.

The lawsuit therefore raised questions about the relationship between presidential authority, congressional legislation and the responsibilities of federal agencies.

It was not simply a disagreement about whether immigration policy should be stricter or more flexible. It was a dispute about whether the government had followed the authority and procedures provided by existing law.

What Happened in the First Federal Court?

The case first went before the US District Court for the District of Columbia.

On July 2, 2025, the district court ruled in favour of the plaintiffs.

The court found important parts of the proclamation’s implementation unlawful and vacated the guidance to the extent that it attempted to replace the existing statutory removal process with new summary expulsion procedures.

It also issued a declaratory judgment concerning the restrictions on asylum and other forms of protection.

The court ordered federal officials, other than the president, not to implement the challenged policy through procedures that violated the legal protections identified in its ruling.

This was significant because the decision did not simply address the personal circumstances of the thirteen individual plaintiffs.

The district court certified a class action involving people affected by the policy who were or would be present in the United States.

A class action allows individuals facing similar legal issues to pursue a shared case through representatives rather than requiring every affected person to file a separate lawsuit.

However, the size and definition of the class later became another point of disagreement between the government and the organisations challenging the policy.

The government appealed the district court’s decision.

What Did the Court of Appeals Decide in April 2026?

The case moved to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

On April 24, 2026, the appeals court issued its decision and upheld the district court’s important findings.

The court concluded that the Immigration and Nationality Act did not give the president authority to create his own removal procedures that displaced the processes established by Congress.

It also rejected the administration’s position that the proclamation could be used to prevent covered people physically present in the United States from applying for asylum under the existing statute.

The court’s reasoning focused on the distinction between entry and removal.

In immigration law, the power to suspend entry is not automatically the same as the power to remove someone who has already entered the country.

The administration had relied on provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act that allow the president to suspend entry of certain categories of foreign nationals when their entry is considered detrimental to US interests.

However, the appeals court concluded that these provisions did not authorise the government to replace Congress’s established removal procedures.

The court explained that the Immigration and Nationality Act already provides specific procedures for removing people who are not legally entitled to remain in the country.

These include regular removal proceedings and a separate expedited removal procedure established by Congress.

The court reasoned that general executive authority to suspend entry could not be transformed into unlimited authority to invent an additional removal system.

This distinction became one of the most important legal points in the case.

The appeals court also considered the statutory right to apply for asylum and the protections available to people who fear persecution or torture if returned to their home countries.

Its conclusion was that the challenged proclamation and guidance were unlawful to the extent that they bypassed the procedures and protections contained in federal law.

The court also upheld the class certification after considering the limits placed on the class during an earlier stage of the proceedings.

However, the decision was not entirely unanimous. Judge Justin Walker filed an opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, raising concerns about aspects of the majority’s reasoning, including the class-action questions.

The full April 24, 2026 Court of Appeals decision explains the court’s reasoning in detail.

Why Is the Trump Administration Challenging the Decision?

The federal government disagrees with the lower courts’ interpretation of presidential immigration powers.

The administration argues that the president has broad authority under the Immigration and Nationality Act to suspend the entry of certain foreign nationals when their entry is considered harmful to American interests.

It also argues that the government must be able to manage the border effectively and respond to situations involving large numbers of people attempting to enter the country.

In its Supreme Court petition, the administration argued that prolonged asylum processing times had contributed to difficulties in managing border enforcement. It also argued that the proclamation had been an important tool in reducing border encounters.

The government’s petition referred to a 93% decline in border encounters after the proclamation took effect.

That figure is the administration’s assertion in its legal filings, not an independent finding that the proclamation alone caused the decline.

The organisations opposing the policy disputed the administration’s explanation, arguing that border crossings had already been falling before the proclamation took effect.

This disagreement illustrates why the legal case should not be reduced to a simple argument about whether stricter immigration enforcement works.

The Supreme Court must examine the legal authority available to the government and how that authority interacts with the statutes enacted by Congress.

The administration also challenges the ability of lower federal courts to issue classwide relief in this situation.

It argues that the district court’s order went beyond the limits Congress placed on judicial injunctions in immigration cases.

The government is therefore seeking a ruling that would reverse the lower court’s conclusions and allow its interpretation of the proclamation to stand.

What Is the Main Legal Argument Against the Administration’s Policy?

The central argument made by the organisations challenging the proclamation is that the president cannot use general immigration authority to override the specific protections and procedures established by Congress.

Their argument begins with the wording of the Immigration and Nationality Act.

Congress provided that people physically present in the United States or arriving there may apply for asylum, regardless of their immigration status and whether they entered through a designated port.

Congress also established specific procedures for deciding asylum applications and handling individuals who may qualify for protection against removal.

The challengers argue that the president cannot simply suspend those statutory rights through a proclamation.

They also argue that the administration’s new removal procedures conflict with the existing legal framework.

The distinction between applying for asylum and receiving asylum is particularly important here.

The challengers do not argue that everyone who crosses the border must be granted protection. Rather, their legal position is that people covered by the statute must be allowed to access the process and have their claims considered under the applicable rules.

This is why the dispute is fundamentally about the relationship between executive power and legislation.

A president has important responsibilities in immigration enforcement. However, those responsibilities operate within a legal framework established by Congress.

The Supreme Court will now have to examine how that framework applies to the proclamation.

What Is the Convention Against Torture, and Why Does It Matter?

The case also involves protections under the Convention Against Torture, an international treaty to which the United States is a party.

The convention is designed to prevent countries from returning people to places where they face a real risk of torture.

US law and regulations provide procedures for considering claims under the convention.

This protection is different from asylum.

An asylum applicant generally needs to show a connection between the feared persecution and one of the legally protected grounds, such as race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or political opinion.

A Convention Against Torture claim focuses on whether the person is likely to be tortured if returned to the proposed country.

The person does not need to demonstrate the same protected-ground connection required for asylum.

The distinction matters because someone may not qualify for asylum but could still qualify for protection against removal under the Convention Against Torture.

The D.C. Circuit examined the government’s replacement screening procedure and concluded that it did not follow the existing regulatory framework.

The court was concerned that the new process offered fewer procedural opportunities for individuals to present evidence and have their claims considered.

It also examined the removal protections provided by the Immigration and Nationality Act.

These issues demonstrate that the case involves more than the word “asylum”. It concerns several connected forms of legal protection that may prevent a person from being returned to a place where they face serious harm.

What Does Section 1252(f)(1) Have to Do With the Case?

The second major issue accepted by the Supreme Court concerns a provision of federal immigration law known as 8 U.S.C. Section 1252(f)(1).

This section places limits on the ability of lower federal courts to issue injunctions that restrain the operation of certain provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act.

An injunction is a court order requiring a party to do something or refrain from doing something.

In this case, the government argues that the district court exceeded its authority by granting relief that applied to a group of affected people rather than limiting the order to the individual plaintiffs.

This is an important distinction because immigration policies can affect large numbers of people.

If a federal court is allowed to issue an order covering a defined class of people, that order can provide protection without requiring every affected person to bring a separate case.

The administration argues that Congress restricted the power of lower courts to issue this type of relief in certain immigration matters.

The D.C. Circuit rejected that interpretation as applied to the district court’s order.

It reasoned that the specific relief in the case did not violate Section 1252(f)(1), including because the court distinguished between injunctions restraining the operation of certain statutory provisions and the separate remedy of vacating unlawful agency guidance under the Administrative Procedure Act.

The government disagrees.

The Supreme Court has now agreed to examine whether Section 1252(f)(1) prevents the classwide relief entered by the district court.

This issue could have consequences beyond the asylum proclamation itself because it concerns the ability of lower federal courts to protect groups of people affected by government immigration policies.

The full wording of 8 U.S.C. Section 1252 is available through the official United States Code website.

What Exactly Has the Supreme Court Agreed to Decide?

On November 13, 2026, the US Supreme Court granted the government’s petition for a writ of certiorari in case number 26-239.

A writ of certiorari is the process through which the Supreme Court agrees to review a decision from a lower court.

However, agreeing to hear a case does not mean that the Court has accepted the government’s arguments or rejected the lower courts’ conclusions.

The Supreme Court’s official docket shows that the justices accepted review on two questions.

The first question: Whether Presidential Proclamation 10888 and its implementing guidance are lawful, including the restrictions that prevent certain people from accessing statutory protections such as asylum.

The second question: Whether Section 1252(f)(1) prevents the classwide relief granted by the district court.

The government had originally presented a third question concerning whether the class definition complied with Article III of the Constitution and Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

The Supreme Court’s November 13 order granted review only on the first two questions.

This means the justices have agreed to examine the legality of the proclamation and the limits on classwide relief, but they have not accepted the separate third question as an independent issue for review.

The official Supreme Court docket for case 26-239 records the November 13 order.

What Could Happen When the Supreme Court Rules?

There are several possible outcomes.

The first possibility is that the Supreme Court agrees with the administration’s interpretation of the law.

If that happens, it could reverse or narrow the lower courts’ decisions and establish that the executive branch has greater authority to restrict access to asylum under the statutory provisions involved in the case.

The Court could also conclude that the district court lacked authority to issue the classwide relief challenged by the government.

A second possibility is that the Court agrees with the challengers and upholds the central reasoning of the D.C. Circuit.

That would reinforce the distinction between presidential authority to suspend entry and the separate procedures Congress established for removing people who are present in the United States.

It could also preserve the classwide protections ordered by the lower courts.

A third possibility is a divided decision.

The justices could agree with one side on the legality of the proclamation but reach a different conclusion on whether the lower court could issue relief covering a defined class of people.

This matters because the two questions are related but not identical.

A court could decide that a government policy violates federal law while also finding that the remedy granted by a lower court must be changed.

The Supreme Court is not required to accept every part of either side’s argument.

It could affirm some aspects of the lower court’s decision, reverse others or send the case back for further proceedings.

Until the justices issue their ruling, it would be inaccurate to claim that the administration has won or that the asylum restrictions have been permanently struck down.

Why Could This Case Matter Beyond the US-Mexico Border?

Although the dispute focuses on the southern border, its legal implications could reach further.

One of the central questions is how far a president can go when using general statutory authority to respond to an immigration situation.

Presidents have significant responsibilities in enforcing immigration laws and managing entry into the country.

However, Congress also has authority to establish the legal procedures governing admission, removal and protection against persecution.

When the executive branch introduces a policy that appears to conflict with those procedures, federal courts may be asked to determine whether the government has acted within its legal powers.

The outcome of Mullin v. RAICES could help clarify the boundaries between those responsibilities.

It may also influence how future governments approach emergency immigration policies.

Another important issue is the power of federal courts to protect groups affected by government action.

If the Supreme Court concludes that Section 1252(f)(1) restricts the type of classwide relief issued in this case, future challenges to immigration policies could face additional procedural difficulties.

On the other hand, if the Court upholds the lower court’s interpretation, it could clarify that certain forms of groupwide relief remain available when the requirements of federal law are satisfied.

For immigrants’ rights organisations, governments and legal practitioners, the decision could therefore become an important reference point in future immigration disputes.

When Will the Supreme Court Hear the Case?

As of November 15, 2026, the Supreme Court has agreed to hear the dispute, but the official docket does not yet list a date for oral arguments.

The Associated Press reported that the justices are expected to hear the case in spring 2027, with a decision anticipated by the end of June 2027.

That is an expected timetable rather than a final judgment or a confirmed argument date.

During oral arguments, lawyers representing the administration and the organisations challenging the policy will have the opportunity to present their positions and answer questions from the justices.

The Court may then consider the arguments, examine the relevant statutes and issue a written opinion.

The outcome will be particularly important because the case involves both the interpretation of federal immigration law and the limits of judicial authority.

Until then, the legal dispute remains unresolved at the Supreme Court level.

What Should Readers Understand About the Case?

The most important point is that the Supreme Court is not deciding whether the United States should have immigration controls or whether every person arriving at the border should be allowed to remain in the country.

The dispute is more specific.

It concerns whether the president can use the statutory powers cited in Proclamation 10888 to prevent certain people from applying for asylum and to establish removal procedures that differ from those enacted by Congress.

It also concerns whether a federal court can issue classwide relief when a government policy affects a defined group of people.

These questions involve the balance of power between the president, Congress and the federal judiciary.

The administration argues that the challenged policy is necessary for border management and falls within presidential authority.

The organisations challenging it argue that the president cannot use that authority to bypass statutory protections and procedures.

Both sides have presented their arguments, and the Supreme Court has now agreed to review the dispute.

Final Thoughts: Can the President Stop People From Seeking Asylum?

The answer is not yet settled by the Supreme Court in this case.

The lower federal courts have ruled that the challenged proclamation and guidance cannot lawfully be used to bypass the protections and removal procedures established by Congress. The administration has challenged those decisions and asked the Supreme Court to review them.

What makes Mullin v. RAICES important is that it goes beyond one immigration policy.

It raises a fundamental legal question about how presidential authority operates when Congress has already established detailed rules governing a particular area of law.

The case also demonstrates why the right to apply for asylum should not be confused with an automatic right to receive it. Applications must still be assessed under the law, and not every applicant qualifies for protection.

For now, the Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case, but the final outcome remains unknown.

The next major stage will be the oral arguments and the Court’s eventual judgment, expected in 2027.

Until that decision is delivered, the legal boundaries of the administration’s challenged policy remain an important question for the American immigration system.


Official Sources and Further Reading

  1. US Supreme Court โ€“ Mullin v. RAICES, Case No. 26-239
  2. Presidential Proclamation 10888 โ€“ Federal Register
  3. 8 U.S.C. Section 1158 โ€“ Asylum
  4. 8 U.S.C. Section 1252 โ€“ Judicial Review of Orders of Removal
  5. US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit โ€“ April 24, 2026 Decision
  6. US Government’s Petition for Supreme Court Review
  7. Respondents’ Brief in Opposition
  8. Associated Press โ€“ Supreme Court to Consider Trump’s Executive Order Suspending Asylum Access

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *